An article came across my desk related to how “poorly” Houston did regarding work commute times, in relation to other cities across the nation. I found the article – while brief and objective – to be misleading, nonetheless.
Here’s why.
The article states that Houston (at #6) ranked below Abiline, TX (at #1).
The longest time in the time range specified for Houston was 29 minutes. By comparison, Abilene was clocked at a speedy 14 minutes for the commute time.
While it seems pretty bad to have to drive twice as long to get to and from work in Houston than in Abilene, let’s consider some factors that were obviously not part of the ranking:
- Total city land mass in Houston = 601.3 sq. miles. Abilene = 110.6 sq. miles.
- Total population in Houston = 2,099,451. Abilene = 117,063
Given that for relative baselines, we run these times through the calculatron:
- Houston is physically bigger than Abilene. Meaning there’s more area to drive from points A to B and back.
But the commute time average in Houston is 0.04 minutes per square mile (29 mins / 601.3 sq. mi) whereas for Abilene it’s a whopping 0.12 minutes per sq. mile (14 mins / 110.6 sq. mi).
That works out to be more than 2.5 times faster in Houston than in Abilene on average.
- Houston has more people living (and driving) in the city than in Abilene. Meaning there are more cars/trucks/SUV/busses/donky carts on the road to drive behind, around, and through.
But the commute time average in Houston is 0.00001 minutes per person (29 mins / 2,099,451 people) whereas for Abilene it’s a whopping 0.00012 minutes per person (117,063 people / 14 minutes).
That works out to be more than 8.5 times faster in Houston than in Abilene on average in this regard.
My conclusion? Houston still wins hands-down, especially when you consider the sheer size and scale of infrastructure in the city. The numbers in the survey and my viewpoint on them show me that this is really a nice place to be.
Not that there’s anything wrong with Abilene – as long as I don’t have to drive to work there.
Smileyface.
References:
http://www.bizjournals.com/houston/news/2012/01/05/houston-has-one-of-texas-worst.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abilene,_Texas
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Houston